Ultimate Guide for Mulches

by Ken Lain, the mountain gardener

Mulch is any material that is spread or laid over the surface of the soil as a covering. It is used to retain moisture in the soil, suppress weeds, keep the soil cool, and make the garden bed look more attractive. Additionally, organic mulches help improve the soil’s fertility as they decompose.


Bark, shredded or chipped


Composted Manure

Grass Clippings


Shredded Leaves


Organic mulch will decompose and have to be replaced, but in the process, it will improve your soil’s fertility and its organic content. The dryer and woodier the mulch, the slower it will decompose and the fewer nutrients it will add to the soil.

It pays to know the origins of manure, compost, and straw since these materials can contain viable weed seeds. The last thing you want is to spread a mulch that is going to start sprouting and make more work for you. Each type of organic mulch has its own use.


Bark mulches are best used around trees, shrubs, and in garden beds where you won’t be doing a lot of digging, like front walkways and foundation plantings. These woody mulches don’t mix well into the soil, and it can become a hassle to have to keep moving them aside to make way for new plants. They will, however, last longer than finer sizes of organic mulches.



Compost and composted manure can be used anywhere, as long as they are relatively well composted and weed free.  You can use them as a coating of mulch or simply side dress plants with them during the growing season to insulate and give a boost of slowly released nutrients.

Grass Clippings

Grass clippings are a mixed bag and are best suited to remote areas of your garden where you want to suppress weeds. Grass clippings, like most green plant debris with a high water content, decompose very rapidly, and in the process, they can get somewhat slimy, with an unpleasant odor, so use with discretion.

Grass clippings also tend to mat down and not allow water to pass through.

Ideally, you should use a mulching mower and leave the clippings on the lawn to add fertility to that soil. If you do bag your grass clippings, don’t throw them away unless you have used weed killer or some other herbicide or pesticide on your lawn. Synthetic lawn care products can be bad for some flowers, and you certainly don’t want to use them in your vegetable garden. Untreated grass clippings can be dumped into your compost bin or used to mulch open, unplanted areas.


Newspaper as mulch is becoming more and more popular. Most newspapers have switched over to organic dyes, especially for their black & white sections. Shredded newspaper has been used for years to keep plant roots moist while shipping. Layered sheets of the newspaper also have great moisture retention abilities, and they act like other organic mulches as far as suppressing weeds and controlling soil temperatures. They also are great for smothering existing grass and to jump-start a new garden bed.

To use as a mulch in the garden spread a layer of four to eight sheets of newspaper around the plants. Moisten the sheets to keep them in place.

On windy days the sheets are easier to work with if you moisten them before you put them in place. Cover the newspaper with a one to three-inch layer of another organic mulch, and weed protection should last throughout the growing season.

Shredded Leaves

Shredded leaves are Nature’s favorite mulch. They can be used as mulch anywhere and have the added bonus of being free. Also, they will entice more earthworms to your garden soil. Some gardeners don’t like the look of leaves in their gardens, and generally, think they’re inappropriate for a formal setting.  If you lay a layer of leaves n the spring before plants spread out, the leaf mulch tends to be hidden by foliage and blends out of sight within a short time. Shredded leaves are perfect for woodland gardens, and if you spread a layer over your vegetable garden in the fall, it will begin decomposing over the winter.

Unshredded leaves can mat together and repel water. If that happens, you can always rake and fluff them up a bit if they appear to get matted.

Straw and Hay

Straw and salt hay are popular mulches for the vegetable garden. They prevent the soil and soil-borne diseases from splashing up on lower plant leaves and make paths less muddy. Straw decomposes very slowly and will last the entire growing season. It also makes a nice home for spiders and other beneficial insects who will move in and help keep the pest population under control. Finally, it’s easy to either rake up or work into the soil when it’s time to plant a new crop or put the vegetable garden to bed.


Black Plastic

Landscape Fabric


Synthetic and inorganic mulches do a good job of retaining moisture and blocking weeds. They don’t add any fertility to the soil, but they don’t decompose so don’t require replacing as often as organic mulches.

 If you like the functionality of plastic or landscape fabric but not the look, you can always add a thin layer of bark mulch as camouflage on top of the plastic or fabric. As the bark decomposes, weed seeds will be able to take hold on top of the materials. You also will need to replace the bark as it disintegrates. If you’re building raised beds, consider making them the width of your plastic or fabric so that you can cover the bed without seams.

Plastic and Landscape Fabric

Plastic and landscape fabric are good choices to use around trees, foundation plantings, and other shrubs where you won’t be working regularly. These plants don’t require frequent fertilization so, for the most part, you won’t have to worry about weeding them throughout the summer.

Plastic gets very hot in Summer’s heat and, besides smothering weed seeds, it also can kill all the good things in the soil, including plant roots, unless there is sufficient moisture. Be sure to cut holes in the fabric to allow sufficient water to pass through the synthetic impenetrable layer.

If you are seeing puddles accumulate on top of the plastic or fabric, you don’t have enough drainage. Landscape fabric is porous and shouldn’t be a problem unless it gets blocked.

Gravel and Stone

Gravel and stonework well as mulches in areas that require good drainage or beds with plants that like a little additional heat, like Mediterranean herb gardens. Stone is hard to remove, so give it a lot of thought before using stone or gravel as a mulch.

Which mulch you choose depends on the function and aesthetic you want. There are more and more choices each year, so review your options before you buy and choose a mulch that will please you for many years.

Until next issue, I’ll be here at Watters Garden Center helping local gardeners with their garden compost issues.

Ken can be found throughout the week at Watters Garden Center, 1815 W. Iron Springs Rd in Prescott, or contacted through his website at WattersGardenCenter.com  or  FB.com/WattersGardenCenter .